A film blog on My Own Private Idaho:
As a film from the New Queer Cinema movement, My Own Private Idaho explores the idea of what home is and what it can be to the queer youth who are finding their place in a heteronormative world. It follows the story of Mike and Scott, who are both male prostitutes. Mike in particular, as a queer man, is longing for something familiar, whether that be through his unrequited love for Scott, his dreams of his mother, or his search for her. I came into the film dreading the Shakespeare, especially since it sources Shakespears historical plays of Henry IV and Henry V, but I left emotionally compelled because of just how differently the story tells itself with the then-unfamiliar aspects of prostitution, narcolepsy, and of course homosexuality.
I am, however, unsure of how to feel about the visuals of some of the film. It definitely makes some interesting visual choices, such as its use of the color orange (the orange fireplace and the orange sky) somewhat giving a warm, comforting feeling when the scene or situation needs it. At other times, the colors are very gray or bland to look at, enhancing the more depressing parts of the film. If you really think about it though, this was a very visually dark film. Even in scenes of broad daylight, the shots still felt pretty dark to me.
Shots that definitely took me out of the movie would be those that tell us where the next scene is. A blank, solid color screen with white letters of where they are is not exactly the best way to express a change in scenery. I read that there were financing problems when it came to getting the film greenlit, but I would’ve expected something less jarring. Heck, maybe even just a shot on location with text saying where they are could’ve been better!

What also threw me off at times were the visual shots of the open road. As someone who isn’t technically proficient with DP work, it’s difficult for me to say if the strange visuals of the open road, the desert, and the time lapse of the sky were thanks to the technology at the time or if it was an actual stylistic choice.


Despite these complaints, however, River Phoenix and Keanu Reeves’ portrayal of Mike and Scott are what definitely sell this film. This is particularly impressive when we remember the context of a less understanding society when it comes to homosexuality and with prostitution.



