Velvet Goldmine is nothing short of gaudy, extravagant, and over-the-top. Glam rock isn’t something you can bullshit, and Velvet Goldmine did not disappoint. The way Brian Slade’s life was presented was so intricate, eloquent, and well-thought-out. There are so many elements of the film that bring out different sides of me—the journalist, the communication major, the philosophy enthusiast. Despite this, I can say all parts of me thoroughly enjoyed the film. Here’s what I loved about the film’s storytelling:
The film’s choice to narrate Brian Slade’s life in the form of flashbacks experienced by journalist Arthur Stuart’s interviewees was crucial to the way the narrative progressed. This gave way for the “headliner-worthy story” perspective on the whole phenomena that is Brian’s life, his staged death, all the works. However, while Arthur was also very immersed in the whole glam rock scene, I personally felt the way the narrative was presented detached Arthur from the rest of the storyline, and that his character wasn’t fleshed out enough. Arthur felt more like a mere plot device, rather than a character with a story of his own. My journalist self tells me it’s because he needs to remain impartial, and that he shouldn’t color his story with his own emotions. However, my communication major self says I wish the film had unpacked his character more.
This also brings in the question of whether Brian Slade is real or not, and who he really is. This is going to sound very philosophical in nature, because the film is always told in first person, just by different people, based on whoever Arthur is interviewing—and because of this, we only get glimpses of how different people viewed Brian. We never see Brian from a totally objective point of view, or Brian from his point of view. We only see how he came across to several characters. We see all of his outward actions, and how these are interpreted by other people. As Levinasian as this sounds, we only see how other people make sense of the other that is Brian Slade. We only see these imposed understandings of him, and there’s this whole other side of Brian that is never explicitly presented—the raw, genuine, human side of him. We only see him as a mere memory, and as Bertrand Russell states, our senses are highly fallible. We all know these interpretations of Brian, no matter how valid—because, of course, we’re all entitled to our own feelings and opinions—can be incredibly flawed and inaccurate. My journalist self would also state that there’s no such thing as completely unbiased news. I guess there’s no way we could find out who Brian Slade really truly is, we only see him for how we want to see him. And I guess this has its own merits. It’s quite paradoxical that we never truly get to know who Brian really is, despite him being the focus of the film. That very sense of mystery is what keeps the film going.
In line with all the interviewees, it’s only logical that Arthur would interview people closest to Brian, which means you’d be listening to stories of the very few people who see Brian as more than just a rock star. You hear from Cecil, who knows what Brian was like when he was just starting out as a rising star. You hear from Mandy, who’s seen Brian at his lowest and most vulnerable. This is interesting because most people only see rock stars like some sort of god, like a higher, ethereal being. But these dark sides of Brian are what reminds us that he, too, is human like us. Sure, he’s presented in such a way that we don’t get to know who he truly is, but we do know that he’s hurt people, and that he wasn’t as perfect as most people thought he was. And maybe that’s human enough for us.
The production design of the film was excellent—there were so many crazy costumes, hair and makeup looks, and set designs. The frequent interspersion of musical numbers even made it feel like a two-hour long music video, which makes the movie really stay true to its glam rock focus. I think the very vibrant presentation of the movie through its production design, with all the glitz and glamour, presents an exceptional juxtaposition when coupled with the complicated subject matter. Not everything that glitters is gold, and this very juxtaposition only highlights the very artificiality that comes with being a rock star. We never really know who Brian is beyond the flashy looks.
There are so many layers to Velvet Goldmine, and the film’s gorgeous and elaborate storytelling is sure to captivate anyone who sees it. Velvet Goldmine definitely makes my list on the most enthralling films of all time, and I can only hope to tell stories as great as this one day.